A podcast about AI in court. Everyone arguing about whether training on copyrighted works violated fair use. Lawyers debating. Companies defending. One argument stuck: if you feed Lord of the Rings into a model and produce derivatives, you decrease the value of the original. Fair enough.
But the whole conversation was one-sided. Every voice was asking: "How do we protect what already exists?"
Nobody was asking: "How do we enable what doesn't exist yet?"
The Parent-Child Problem
Every human artist who ever lived learned by consuming other people's work. Tolkien read Norse mythology, Beowulf, and carried the trenches of WWI into Middle-earth. Nobody sued him for "training on" the Edda. A painter studies Monet. A musician grows up on Miles Davis. They absorb, they transform, and they create something new.
We don't call that copyright infringement. We call it learning. AI is doing the same thing through a different mechanism.
If a parent teaches a child everything they know, and the child goes on to create something remarkable — does the parent own the child's work? Of course not.
The Real Fear
Strip away the legal arguments and what's left? People aren't really afraid of copyright infringement. They're afraid of becoming unnecessary. But AI has a long way to go. Even in coding, you still have to tell it what you want. AI can generate. It can't yet feel.
The Answer Isn't Prohibition — It's Provenance
The question shouldn't be "how do we stop AI from using copyrighted material." The question should be: "How do we build a system where everyone wins?"
Original creators get attribution and compensation. New creators get access to the full breadth of human knowledge. AI platforms get clear rules. The public gets new art and new possibilities. You don't solve copyright with walls. You solve it with transparency.
If every AI-assisted creation carries a transparent chain of custody showing what influenced it, you have the infrastructure for fair attribution. You can trace the lineage. You can compensate the sources. This is why PROVENANCE exists in the CORVAI™ framework. This is why the audit trail matters.